Nonpharmacologic Approaches to Insomnia in Older Adults

The Magnitude of Sleep interruption in elder Adults Sleep interruption is a substantial problem for elderly adults. Many alterations in sleep architecture have been noticeable with age. The most striking shift in sleep for elderly adults is an increment in the amount of nightly wakenings. Diminutions in sleep efficiency (ratio of time in bed at rest to time in bed), sum sleep time, and the measure of time passed in heavy or slow-wave sleep are usual. While an enfeebling of the suprachiasmatic cores (the minds biological clock) might explain a few of these alterations in the context of natural maturing, it's more plausible that declinations in sleep in an aged person are ascribable to modifications in health and welfare. Age, cognitive condition, and medical encumbrance seem to augur consequent descents in sleep efficiency. Sleep gets more and more interrupted with diminutions in physical wellness, and solid ties have been ascertained between anxiousness and clinical depression and interrupted sleep.

Acquiring a good night’s sleep for long-term attention (LTC) occupants turns out to be more difficult than for community-based elderly adults. While 4% of community-based elder adults conform to the characteristic standards for insomnia, it's calculated that 6% of LTC occupiers fulfill the measures, and 17% describe at the least one of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th version, text revisal measures. While insomnia is a substantial problem in LTC, less than 25% of occupants with insomnia undergo treatment. Common complaints include trouble falling asleep and trouble remaining asleep, and reports of sleep in nursing homes (NHs) manifest really disconnected sleep. The effect is that, in spite of occupants passing additional time in bed than community-based samples, sleep efficiency is substantially inferior (48-72%).

Sleep troubles may be yet more difficult for persons with dementedness. About 19-54% of persons with dementia have problems with sleep, defined by diminished aggregate sleep time, less slow-wave and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep, and regular nighttime wakenings., Sleep-related disorientation, referred to as confusional rousings, as well as turmoil and roaming, could follow nighttime wakenings. Aberrant motions such as stereotypical repetitious flexure of the legs and/or dream portrayal might be observed. Sleep interruption may be likewise due to harm to the neural pathways related to the suprachiasmatic cores. Medicine used to treat dementedness can contribute to sleep interruption: donepezil may increment REM sleep, diminish REM sleep response time, or increment nightmares, while galantamine might decrement REM sleep latency and slow-wave sleep. Comorbid sicknesses and basic sleep disarrays can likewise impart significantly to sleep dysregulation.

One exceptional universe of elderly adults are partners presuming the function of caregivers for an person with dementia; they frequently work in a loaded down agenda, akin to a revolving shift worker only without very much predictability. Afterwards, sleep disruptions (for example, common nightly wakenings, briefer sleep time, expanded wake time after sleep oncoming) are really common. The caliber of the caregiver’s sleep is directly related to the level of cognitive damage and nightly action of the individual being tended to, but likewise to the caregiver’s age and psychological and personal wellness. These, in the long run, may become one of the most potent components in choosing to commit the stricken person.

Not unexpected, daytime drowsiness was ascertained to be a substantial problem, with daytime sleep interfering with engagement in daytime actions and socialising, and expanding the odds of nightly wakenings. A meaningful component of the day could be expended “drowsing,” especially in the instance of institutionalized elderly adults or those with dementia, to the degree of daytime sleep becoming commensurate in length to that of nighttime sleep. In addition, with more medical sicknesses and disabilities, a lot of elderly adults expend lengthier time in their rooms, in bed, and seldom go out of doors where they'd be exposed to physical illumination. E.g., there seems to be a correlativity between harshness of dementedness in a person and degrees of light exposure: the more serious the dementia, the less measure of light obtained. Community-dwelling senior individuals with modest dementia were accounted to experience less than 30 minutes of brilliant light exposure per twenty-four hours, while for a NH occupant, light exposure was described to average ten minutes per day. Decreased light exposure does mold the circadian cycle ordinance, ensuing in early-morning arousing and fragmentised sleep. Additional environmental components that cause a result upon circadian rhythms, such as bodily activeness and day-to-day cultural fundamental interaction, are frequently inadequate likewise.

Results of Insomnia and Interrupted Sleep

In recent years, insomnia has been the target of expanded investigation owing to its biopsychosocial, objective, and healing importance. Insomnia has been connected to daytime somnolence, weakened cognitive power including attention and retention, disruptions in psychomotor operating, and retarded reaction time. Slowed down reaction time is especially crucial as it can bear upon driving ability and increment the hazard of tumbles. Additional disabilities affiliated with insomnia include inability to relish fellowship and societal kinships, augmented incidence of painful sensation, reduced ability to carry out day-to-day chores, inferior self-rated health, and expanded intake of health care resources. In a survey of sleep and psychogenic wellness in senior individuals without clinical depression, insomnia was observed to be the soundest prognosticator of clinical depression at 3-year reexamination. Insomnia has been demonstrated to be affiliated with more insufficient mental and sociable welfare, contributing to a more depleted character of living. Especially in males, insomnia was ascertained to be the most substantial forecaster of both death rate and NH emplacement.

In a longitudinal report of more than 6000 men and women age sixty-five years and older who were cognitively whole at baseline, degenerative symptoms of insomnia were ascertained to make up a substantial and autonomous danger component for cognitive diminution in men without clinical depression. Chronic insomnia in elderly adults is connected with damage in retention, specifically subdued execution in acquisition value and in temporal arrangement assessment, in addition to significantly abbreviated immunity to proactive hindrance. A connection between insomnia and high blood pressure was identified, with insomnia cases defined by less articulated nighttime fall in both systolic and diastolic blood pressure as likened with controls. Sleep length lately was ascertained to be a risk element for the evolution of diabetes in senior men, with both abbreviated (< 5 hr) and lengthy (> 9 hr) sleep durations connected with an expanded relative incidence of diabetes, developing a U-shaped dispersion of risk.


The aetiology of insomnia in elderly adults is oftentimes juxtaposed against medical circumstances (comorbid insomnia). Preceding management approach to insomnia proposed that if insomnia came about within the circumstance of comorbidity, the common medical malady should be the center of treatment. Nevertheless, this doesn't account for the more intricate nature of insomnia. In the context of a medical precondition or different sleep disruptor working as a causative result, insomnia originates because of predisposing conditions (for example, high trait anxiousness) and perpetuating agents (for instance, inactiveness, inordinate napping during the daytime). Furthermore, it's probable that in most types of insomnia amid elderly adults, there are manifold causative agents, both behavioural and physical. Elements such as pre-existing medical circumstances and psychiatrical illness, including sleep disarrays, and medicines to care for these disorders, age-related shifts in sleep architecture, circadian consequences (for example, atypical sleep/awake cycle, confined light exposure, inordinate time in bed), host components such as an enhanced disposition to hyperarousal, a personality inclined to worry, and “lark versus owl” disposal can each interface and impart to insomnia. Environmental components and inadequate sleep habits can perpetuate troubles with insomnia.

A complete valuation is called for to ascertain the particular agents contributive to insomnia in each elderly adult. To distinguish crucial contributors, a consummate sleep chronicle should be obtained, including a reassessment of current and preceding medical circumstances, psychiatrical maladies, and a reexamination of previous and present-day medicines. A physical exam and lab evaluation as suggested from the account are advocated to back up the history and active wellness problems.

Standard Instruments for Appraising Sleep Symptoms

A diagnosis of insomnia is created from personal accounts of ability to sleep, sleep disturbance, or unrefreshing nature of sleep affiliated with daylight results. While sleep polysomnography is an impersonal process that might be employed for quantifying sleep induction and sustentation variables, insomnia by itself isn't presently viewed an indicant for polysomnography. If signaled, a nighttime polysomnogram might allow for significant data about the presence of additional sleep disarrays typically observed in maturing adults (for instance, sleep-related respiration disorder, arm motion disorders) that may add to insomnia.

Sleep journal

A sleep journal is a semistructured or organised form employed by patients for entering sleep/wake action. It can deviate in complexity from an elementary log labeling bedtime, nightly wakenings, and morning wake times to a more elaborate journal of daytime actions that could act upon sleep. Sleep journals should be made out for one to 2 weeks. Once a baseline sleep model is set up, sleep journals can be employed by the patient and provider to supervise treatment progression and symptom reoccurrence.

Insomnia Severity Index

The Insomnia Severity Index is a 7-item questionnaire utilized to evaluate the harshness of insomnia, satisfaction with present-day sleep, sleep disturbance, and the patient’s and others’ concerns with the sleeping problem. Marks run from 0-28, with scores bigger than 8 connotative insomnia.

Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index

The Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index is a 19-item questionnaire with an advanced test-retest dependability and dependable cogency. It's an efficient tool in assessing the character and formulas of sleep in the elderly adult. It distinguishes “bad” from “effective” sleep by valuing 7 areas: subjective sleep quality, sleep latent period, sleep length, customary sleep efficiency, sleep disruptions, usage of sleeping medicine, and daytime disfunction across the preceding calendar month. The patient self-rates each of these 7 areas of sleep. Tallying of responses is founded on a 0-3 scale, with 3 reflecting the unfavorable extreme point on the Likert Scale. A global amount of 5 or larger signaled a “deficient” sleeper and ensued in a predisposition of almost 99% and specificity of 84% as a marker for sleep disruptions in patients with insomnia versus controls.

Epworth Sleepiness Scale

The Epworth Sleepiness Scale is a self-estimate of sleep proclivity in dissimilar conditions and is generally used to approximate the level of drowsiness in patients with insomnia, preventative sleep apnea, narcolepsy, and hypersomnia. Patients rank how probable they are to fall asleep or drift off in 8 assorted situations normally found in day-to-day life. Marks deviate from 0-24, with scores greater than 10 suggestive of substantial daytime sleepiness.

Caregiver Accounts

Caregiver reports have been employed, while not tested, to diagnose insomnia in situations when employment of self-assessment instruments such as sleep journals and self-report sleep questionnaires are not feasible (for example, individuals with intense cognitive damage, NH occupiers). Since the preceding observed instruments are fashioned as self-report criteria, there are great restrictions when someone other than the patient is describing the symptoms, such as a health care provider.


Actigraphy allows for nonsubjective information when assessing insomnia complaints. Actigraphy isn't an option to the nighttime polysomnogram but could be valuable in appraising activity-wake models, especially since it is deployed across aggregate sequential days and is done in a patient’s common surroundings, minimising disadvantageous outcomes from sleep in a research laboratory. Among the most productive arenas of employment is the LTC setting; there are great limits in getting self-reported information, as well as the feasibleness of polysomnographic screening, in this universe. Actigraphy is commonly employed for a period of 7-14 days and could help with the derivative diagnosis, steer treatment recommendations, and evaluate outcomes. Many devices have a light detector, which may assist in distinguishing more precisely the bedtime and wake-up times, and renders data about timing of light exposure; it could be applied as well in covering adherence to light therapy and suggested dim-light time period. Actigraphy shouldn't be utilized exclusively, but instead in co-occurrence with a sleep journal to direct grading and reading of information.

Alternatives for Management of Insomnia

Because medical and psychiatrical statuses have a substantial influence on sleep, optimizing management of implicit disarrays should be part of the initial step, as it might improve sleep disturbance. E.g., Caring for clinical depression, handling pain, and eliminating intense sickness such as urinary contagions may address interrupted sleep problems. Since medications may increment stimulation, contribute to drowsiness, or negatively act upon the circadian rhythm, adjustments in the timing of medicines (for instance, antidepressants) may likewise enhance slumber.

Hypnotics can decrement time to doze off and wake time during the nighttime, but there are worries about drawn-out employment in the elderly adults owing to danger of side effects. E.g., Thirty% of older adults who pick up a new prescription drug for benzodiazepines (BZDs) report at least regular usage two months afterward. Discontinuance of BZD treatment for insomnia can be a demanding chore. In a sample of elderly adults observed for a 2-year time period, roughly 43% of the persons had restarted BZD usage.

Insomnia in advanced life tends to be degenerative and recurring, so long-term disease management schemes are required. Cognitive behavioural strategies have been described to be most efficient in handling insomnia over time.

Elements of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy for Insomnia

Cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) is a multidimensional approach that aggregates mental and behavioural therapies to care for insomnia. These include sleep hygienics, sleep limitation, stimulant control, relaxation behavior methods, and cognitive therapy. CBT-I use for a particular patient might include disparate levels and portions of these therapies.

Sleep Hygiene

Sleep hygiene measurements are frequently the initiatory class of intercession applied (either unaccompanied or in combination with soporific handling) to address insomnia Sleep hygiene employs commonsensical interventions to advance sleep, such as trimming down environmental constituents (for instance, turning off television) and intrinsical factors (for example, curtailing stimulants before bedtime) that can interrupt sleep. Sleep hygienics has been connected to sleep exercises and, successively, to general sleep character. Interventions to improve sleep hygiene practices may be more inefficient than other cognitive behavioural interventions as a report by McCrae et al suggested that elderly persons with sleep complaints didn't inevitably engage in more inadequate sleep hygiene practices (for instance, alcoholic beverage, cigarette, and caffeine usage; asymmetrical bed and out-of-bed times) than noncomplainers, consequently making sleep hygiene as a sole therapy for late-life insomnia contestable in its efficaciousness.

Sleep Limitation

Sleep restriction employs a persons innate circadian rhythm and homeostatic sleep force to govern sleep and wake models Sleep limitation interventions center on confining time in bed and daytime napping, and fending off unplanned drowsing. Generally based on sleep journals saved for 2 weeks before the intervention, the quantity of time expended in bed is abridged to a number nearer to the approximated real time slumbering. Once sleep efficiency (aggregate sleep time split by time expended in bed) betters, the time allowed for in bed might be bit by bit expanded in moderate increments until the individual’s optimum sleep time is found or sleep efficiency declines.

Stimulant Command

Stimulus control interventions concentrate on boiling down qualified deportments that could interfere with sleep For instance, patients could pass expanded hours in bed viewing television or executing additional actions, disciplining the body to employ the bed as a site for activeness rather than sleep. Stimulus control interventions might include pre-bedtime wind down and/or strategies for constraining the time lying wide-awake in bed looking to doze off, as well as during the day.

Relaxation Behavior

Relaxation processes are employed to produce a repose reaction, help handle anxiousness, and ready the body for sleep These interventions are best fitted for persons who have troubles with nodding off.

Cognitive Interventions

Cognitive interventions address dysfunctional sleep-related opinions or interfering pre-sleep cognitions and normally call for the aid of an individual educated in these therapies. A referral to a prepared behavioural sleep medical specialist may be suggested.

Pertinency of CBT-I in Elderly Adults

Older age wasn't determined to be a roadblock to productive treatment results in employing cognitive behavioural therapy. An organized followup of the research upon the effectuality of these therapies suggests that any individual therapy isn't as efficient as when interventions are aggregated. Amid patients describing habitual sleep troubles, long-term hypnotic expenditure, and upper degrees of comorbidity, usage of CBT-I was affiliated with meaningful improvements in sleep latency, sleep efficiency, and global sleep calibre. Most advances in sleep quality were preserved at 3-6 month followup. Inferior health condition at baseline, critical sickness episodes, and hospitalisations were the most ordinarily referenced rationalities for dropout.

Stimulus restraint and sleep limitation methods have potent data support for abridging wake after sleep onslaught, maximising sleep efficiency, and expanding aggregate sleep time, and were most assistive in developing improvements across a median 6-month followup period of time. Cognitive reconstituting and sleep hygienics are less considered and haven't exhibited their usefulness as stand-alone therapies. A meta-analysis of nearly sixty reports appraising nonpharmacologic handling of habitual insomnia determined that a medium of 5 hours of CBT-I therapy was furnished. More reports have indicated that more controlled interventions and interventions directed by RNs may be assistive to patients with insomnia. CBT-I was determined to be facilitative when allotted in personal face-to-face treatment, in group therapy sittings, or through abbreviated phone contact. Another report employing 2 sittings of CBT-I contributed to bigger improvement for degenerative basic insomnia subjects than 2 sittings of general sleep hygienics instruction.

Efficacy joined with minimum side effects causes behavioural interventions extremely commended for addressing insomnia. All the same, most data come from research reports utilising highly specialized personnel such as psychologists, many of them disciplined in behavioural Sleep Medicine (BSM). Components such as price, want of accessibility of behavioral sleep medicine specialists, and possible problems with patient cognitive condition, physical restrictions, motivation, and conformity may promote disputes in carrying out the usage of CBT-I processes.

Circadian Rhythm Modulators

As reported before, the circadian portion of sleep physiology can dull with age. In addition, controlled exposure to glaring light (= 2000 lux/day) can bring down melatonin levels, upsetting circadian rhythms, and might predispose persons to insomnia or perpetuate an extant insomnia.

Light therapy tries to readjust the stage of the circadian rhythm comparative to the light-dark cycle and likewise might act upon the output of melatonin, which helps sync an individual’s circadian rhythm Bright light presents an abstract menace of retinal harm in vulnerable persons (proliferative diabetic retinopathy, modest or grave macular degeneracy, or absence of a innate or simulated lens in either eye). While at first brilliant white light (a combined spectrum of wavelengths akin to daylight) was used to maintain light effects on human circadian rhythm, short-wavelength blue light (roughly 460 nanometer) may have bigger phase-shifting attributes than the remainder of the visible radiation spectrum; even so, there are still doubts about whether this is to become the favored process to determine the biological clock in the aged.

Physical activity has been ascertained to be a helpful adjunctive therapy and improves aggregate sleep duration, sleep-onset latency, and scores on a scale of global sleep character. Benefits might expand beyond common physical action (for instance, walking); specifically, a curriculum of tai chi chuan improved sleep-onset latency with 18 minutes and sleep length with 48 minutes as likened with low-impact exercise participants.

There's emergent evidence that an orderly and organized day-to-day routine could have advantageous effects on the calibre of nightly slumber. Prior work in this arena ascertained that subjects with greater levels of life style regularity describe fewer sleep troubles. Expanded stableness in day-to-day routine was lately described to anticipate more abbreviated sleep latency and improved sleep character, separate of operative condition, comorbidities, and age. Consequently, interventions projected at governing patients’ day-to-day rhythms and sustenance of a societal rhythm metric would in all likelihood be advantageous; these rationales already have been employed in patients with bipolar affective disarray with effective consequences (social rhythm therapy).

Tailoring Behavioural Intercessions in LTC

Deviations in surroundings, wellness, and degree of independency on persons in LTC settings may argue for a clear-cut approach to CBT-I interventions as likened to those employed in community-based elderly adults. It's probable that a few of the facets of conventional CBT-I, especially regarding the cognitive facets of this therapy, wouldn't be practical or would be of trivial value to this universe. In this circumstance, behavioural therapies are most serviceable, and even when applied solely, have resulted in advantageous results with continuance and betterment of sleep patterns for at least 2 years. Behavioral interventions to improve sleep in LTC settings must be customised to the particular needs of each occupant, and therapies should be selected to target demeanors that are most probable to bear upon the particular resident’s sleep problems. While usage of depressants isn't promoted, employment of short-acting non-BZD agents has been recommended by many in designated cases in concurrence with behavioural therapies to optimise treatment effectivity of both. It's been indicated that once individuals go through success with behavioural strategies, they could acquire the self-assurance to comfortably taper hypnotic use without lapsing. Prognosticators of reversion include insomnia harshness, psychological suffering, and amount of sober weeks.

Particularised Facets in Persons With Dementedness

Because of often unwanted side effects of pharmacological agents in persons with dementia, CBT-I would be a perfect intervention to apply. Plainly, there are restrictions with respect to the cognitive facet of this therapy in an individual with dementia. Consequently, behavioural and environmental interventions seem most practicable and have included cutting back daytime in-bed time, expanding societal and bodily activity, and modifying the surroundings to make it more conducive to nighttime sleep. However, interventions that require changing established bedtime and waking routines and keeping a person with dementia awake during the day can be difficult for family caregivers and establishments to attain.

Among the most productive interventions was described in the Nighttime Insomnia Treatment and Education for Alzheimer's (NITE-AD) program, which covered an 8-week aggregated intervention that included sleep hygiene training, regular walking (thirty min), and enhanced light exposure (1 hour employing a light box). This was affiliated with a 32% decrease in time passed awake during the nighttime as likened with controls, with effects preserved at 6-month reexamination.


In light of the manifold interfaces of sleep with numerous additional elements including comorbidity, life style, and surroundings, as well as expanded hazards with tranquilising agents, due to the auspicious benefit/risk profile, nonpharmacologic standards should be viewed as the premiere course of therapy in any program for optimum long-term control of insomnia. This could translate to more beneficial sleep-related results with the benefit of possibly bringing down the chance of side effects from hypnotic therapy by employing more depressed dosages than otherwise called for. In the final stage, a multicomponent strategy applying cautiously conceived interventions and goals of therapy will in all likelihood allow for most benefits while minimizing undesirable outcomes.




“Under the care of Leo J. Borrell, M.D. since December 2001, I have seen a remarkable improvement in my mother’s condition. She is responding dramatically to the new regiment Dr. Borrell has prescribed”

- Beth Rose


Oct 24, 2008

A Comprehensive Review of Psychiatric Care in Long-Term Care Facilities

 by Dr. Leo J. Borrell, featured in Assisted Living Consul. A HealthCom Media Publication

Feb 3, 2008

The Interdisciplinary Team; The Role of the Psychiatrist

by Dr. Leo J. Borrell, featured in Assisted Living Consult for November/December 2006. A HealthCom Media Publication

Jsn 14, 2008

Psychiatric Options in the Treatments of Seniors

by Dr. Leo J. Borrell, featured in Assisted Living Consult for September/October 2006. A HealthCom Media Publication